CO129-125 - Sir MacDonnell - 1867 [10-11] — Page 190

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

some distance of Hong Kong, I now transmit to Your Grace a copy of a letter which I have received from Sir Rutherford Alcock, which more especially bears upon what I considered the most important point, viz. the probability of including the Lamma Island within our jurisdiction.

Those Sir Rutherford's despatch is accompanied by a Memorandum drawn up by Sir Edmund Hornby. I also transmit my reply to the British Minister's Despatch.

I have not had an opportunity of ascertaining the soundness of Sir Rutherford's Opinion. It is clear, however, that he was convinced of the "utter hopelessness of any attempt to obtain by negotiation the cession of the barren rock in the Chinese Seas," and that consequently, it would be most unwise to commence negotiations towards inducing the Chinese Government to grant jurisdiction for this Government over the Lamma Island, as it would without doubt fail.

From the position, however, Sir Rutherford Alcock ...

Edit History

2026-05-19 22:42:46 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
some distance of Hong Kong, I now transmit to Your Grace a copy of a letter which I have received from Sir Rutherford Alcock, which more especially bears upon what I considered the most important point, viz. the probability of including the Lamma Island within our jurisdiction. Those Sir Rutherford's despatch is accompanied by a Memorandum drawn up by Sir Edmund Hornby. I also transmit my reply to the British Minister's Despatch. I have not had an opportunity of ascertaining the soundness of Sir Rutherford's Opinion. It is clear, however, that he was convinced of the "utter hopelessness of any attempt to obtain by negotiation the cession of the barren rock in the Chinese Seas," and that consequently, it would be most unwise to commence negotiations towards inducing the Chinese Government to grant jurisdiction for this Government over the Lamma Island, as it would without doubt fail. From the position, however, Sir Rutherford Alcock ...
Baseline (Original)
سمون بیسیم certain distance of Honghong, I now kramsnit to Your Grace al copy of a letter which I have received from Fir Rutherford Alcock, which more especially bears upon @ what I considered most important point, viz. the probability of including the Lamma Island abready within anneng. those Jurisdiction Sir Rutherford's despatch aep by A Memeran duan dre The NI. general view of the Question drawn Sir Elmand. Koraby, at Hornby. also transmit my reply British Minister's Despatch . I have 010 of in 159 Loi ascertaining the soundness of Ser Rutherford's Opinion. It is clear. however, that he was convinced of the "utter hopelessness of any "attempt to obtain by negotiation " the cession of the most burren ""rock in the Chinese Beas," and that consequently, it would be most unwise to commence the negotiations towards inclucing Chinese Government to grant jurisdiction for this Government. the Lamma Island, ever as would without doubt fail. to the N. 2 of they From the position, however, Fir Rutherford Alcock, he جو کہ صیح ہیں ہم alone be judge in this matter;
2026-05-19 22:42:46 · Baseline
View content

سمون بیسیم

certain distance of Honghong, I now kramsnit to Your Grace

al

copy of a letter which I have received from Fir Rutherford Alcock, which more especially

bears upon

@

what I considered

most important point, viz.

the probability of including the

Lamma Island

abready

within

anneng.

those

Jurisdiction

Sir Rutherford's despatch

aep by

A

Memeran duan

dre

The

NI.

general view of the Question drawn

Sir Elmand. Koraby, at

Hornby.

also transmit my reply

British Minister's Despatch .

I have

010

of in

159

Loi

ascertaining the soundness of Ser Rutherford's Opinion. It is clear. however, that he was convinced

of the "utter hopelessness of any "attempt to obtain by negotiation

"

the cession of the most burren

""rock in the Chinese Beas," and

that consequently, it would be

most unwise to commence

the

negotiations towards inclucing Chinese Government to grant

jurisdiction for this Government.

the Lamma Island,

ever

as

would without doubt fail.

to the N. 2

of

they

From the position, however, Fir Rutherford

Alcock, he

جو کہ صیح ہیں ہم

alone be judge in this matter;

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.